New Water Agency Risks Repeating SOE Failures, Quiet Privatization

Little hope for fixing South Africa's drying taps
Photo: iStock via News

President Cyril Ramaphosa has acknowledged a national crisis regarding water in South Africa, detailing the challenges in his weekly letter to the nation. The President stated, "We must acknowledge that in too many municipalities, government has not succeeded with the maintenance of infrastructure, to manage water services properly and to respond with sufficient urgency." He further noted that parts of the country are experiencing worsening water shortages and deteriorating water quality, with ageing water infrastructure having collapsed in some municipalities. Ramaphosa's candid assessment shows the severity of the situation facing the nation's vital water resources.

Acknowledging the Crisis

President Cyril Ramaphosa has acknowledged that government has not succeeded in maintaining infrastructure, managing water services properly, or responding with sufficient urgency in a significant number of municipalities. He noted that worsening water shortages and deteriorating water quality are being experienced in parts of the country. Ramaphosa stated that ageing water infrastructure has collapsed in some areas, contributing significantly to the crisis. This collapse of infrastructure has led to widespread service disruptions and concerns about public health. Ramaphosa also reiterated commitments made in his State of the Nation Address, asserting that civil servants and municipal managers deemed responsible for water disasters would be held accountable, signaling a move towards greater responsibility within the public sector. He emphasized that the government is fully aware of the dire state of water services and the urgent need for intervention.

The New Agency's Mandate

A new state-owned enterprise, the National Water Resources Infrastructure Agency Limited, is currently being established to address the deteriorating water supply system in South Africa. The agency's mandate involves taking control of all water infrastructure. The idea is that the agency will take over all water infrastructure and use the revenue and asset value derived from that to negotiate private investment, or public-private partnerships. This strategy aims to secure funding for the replacement or updating of existing water infrastructure, which is currently in a state of disrepair across many municipalities. The agency is envisioned as a central body capable of attracting the necessary capital to revitalize the country's water systems.

Concerns Over Privatization and SOE Track Record

The article questions whether the establishment of the National Water Resources Infrastructure Agency Limited amounts to a quiet form of privatization. Critics suggest the new agency could effectively become another Eskom, providing water services instead of electricity, with similar operational and financial challenges. The article expresses skepticism that the private sector will engage unless there is clear financial profitability, raising doubts about the feasibility of securing significant private investment for potentially unprofitable but essential services. The article posits the new agency might serve as a channel for the deployment of "comrades," reflecting pessimism given the historical failures of most other state-owned enterprises in South Africa. This concern notes a lack of public trust in the management and efficiency of government-owned entities, fearing a repetition of past mistakes rather than a genuine solution to the water crisis. The suggestion is that without fundamental changes in governance and accountability, the new agency could simply replicate the problems seen in other struggling SOEs.

Future Outlook for Water Services

The National Water Resources Infrastructure Agency Limited is being established with the mandate to assume control of all water infrastructure in South Africa. Its strategy involves using revenue and asset value from this infrastructure to negotiate private investment, or public-private partnerships, to fund upgrades. Concerns remain about the agency's potential to become another Eskom, and whether the private sector will engage without clear financial profitability. The article suggests that the new agency could be a place for the deployment of 'comrades', further fueling pessimism given the track record of other state-owned enterprises. The success of this new venture hinges on its ability to overcome these significant challenges and deliver on its promise to revitalize the nation's water supply.